[Take 2 . . . ]
I have been a student of the U.S. Constitution for nearly 50 years. Yesterday, the conservative Catholic majority on the Supreme Court in Town of Greece v. Galloway simply ignored the First Amendment in giving the green light for town councils starting their meetings with sectarian prayers.
The Town of Greece decision has nothing to do with free
speech and everything to do with Christian dominion. The five
conservative Roman Catholics -- Chief Justice Roberts and Justices
Scalia, Thomas, Kennedy and Alito -- did an end run around the
Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. That clause prohibits
government preferring one religion over another or religion over non
religion. In other words, under the First Amendment governments must neutrality with respect to religion.
So what
does the Catholic cabal on the Court do if the Constitution gets in their way of allowing governments to promote Christianity -- simple -- ignore it. Justice Kennedy, writing for the majority, made up a sham legal
argument like our country's heritage permits town councils to open their meetings with Christian prayers. Strange, it's not my Atheistic heritage or the heritage of minority
religions. Rather Christian prayer is an evangelistic tactic of a tyrannical majority (or maybe just a few council members) foisting their religion on their community. In so doing, notwithstanding the majority's holding in Town of Greece, the
Constitution's mandate of separation of government and religion is violated.
And
guess what -- there's no appeal of the Supreme Court's decision. The
justices are not truly bound by the Constitution because they have life
tenure. We can and do criticized them but this bad decision is likely to stand
for decades until there is a fundamental change in the composition of
the Court.
Oh, and by the way, the justices in the minority weren't much better -- for they would still permit prayers at government meetings as long as the prayers were nonsectarian. Prayer is prayer is prayer. It necessarily causes excessive governmental entanglement with religion in violation of the First Amendment.
No comments:
Post a Comment